Tuesday, December 18, 2012

Revision (Response 1)


Killing a person is wrong. Although in certain cases it's seen as "less wrong." In the story "My Parent's Bedroom"  Monique's father kills Maman in order to save his children. Can this really be seen as "less wrong?" He in fact did the right thing. He saved multiple lives but sacrificed one, a utilitarian would had agreed. He chose the side of the majority's benefits over the minority's benefit. If he were to not kill Maman, she would still be killed along with his life and the children's. The situation he was in, he had to protect others. A survival instinct must had triggered to save himself as well, whether or not killing is right or wrong probably didn't go through his head.

The time he had to think was very short, he had to act fast and think fast. Surrounded by a group of vicious men with weapons in hand, given a machete and told to kill, he had no other choice but to kill or be killed. His actions no matter if he killed her or not wouldn't had mattered. The men wanted her dead, and it would had been better if he killed her in a mercy killing for his family rather then cold blooded murder. Monique's father killing Maman is a case in which the killing of another person could be seen "less wrong." Killing a person is wrong, but in Monique's Father's case his killing is less wrong.